The Yankees’ biggest offseason need has one big piece locked in.
In somewhat of a surprising move, David Bednar accepted the $23.15 million qualifying offer ahead of Tuesday’s deadline, ensuring the Yankees will have their reliable closer back for however much of a season is played in 2027.
There were many who thought that the 32-year-old right-hander would reject the offer and try to land a bigger overall deal on the free agent market (at a lower average annual value), but instead Bednar took the one-year pact that will make him the highest-paid reliever in the sport by AAV. It is still possible he and the Yankees could try to negotiate a long-term deal that would lower his AAV.
The $23.15 million is a high number for a closer, but the Yankees already know Bednar can pitch and perform in The Bronx, after he posted a 2.39 ERA with 45 saves in 86 appearances across a season and a half since they acquired him from his hometown Pirates at the 2025 trade deadline. He also allowed just one run in nine playoff innings.
Getting Bednar back in the fold is a critical piece of rebuilding the Yankees bullpen, which GM Brian Cashman acknowledged last week was his biggest priority this offseason. They got started by agreeing to re-sign lefty Tim Hill to a one-year, $2.25 million deal, and now have Bednar joining him with a return. The Yankees also have interest in bringing back veteran Paul Blackburn, who emerged as a valuable bullpen arm last season while making the full-time transition from starting.
This marks the second straight year the Yankees have extended a qualifying offer and had a player accept it, after Trent Grisham did so last year. Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers joined Bednar in accepting the qualifying offer Tuesday, the only two to do so out of the eight players who received one.
It is also the most money the Yankees have committed to a closer since 2019, when they signed Zack Britton to a three-year, $39 million deal and added an extra year and $18 million to the five-year, $86 million contract Aroldis Chapman signed entering 2017.
At least for now, the Yankees are only on the hook for one year of big money to Bednar, who made $9 million last season in his final year of arbitration eligibility.
But it may be worth the price for the Yankees. The other top reliever on the market, former Padres lefty Adrian Morejon, is expected to land a pricey multiyear deal — and, after rejecting the qualifying offer Tuesday — will cost the team signing him draft pick compensation and international bonus pool money.
Go beyond the box score with the Bombers
Sign up for Inside the Yankees by Greg Joyce, exclusively on Sports+.
Thank you
The Yankees also could have tried to trade for Brewers closer Trevor Megill, but that would have cost them player capital for one year of a player whose ability to handle New York is unknown.
Relievers are arguably the most volatile position in the sport, and as recently as April 2025, Bednar was demoted to Triple-A because of his struggles with the Pirates. But he was sturdy and trustworthy since he arrived in The Bronx, and he has never been on the injured list because of an arm injury.
Teammates and coaches also hailed Bednar for his leadership and setting the culture in the Yankees bullpen, which recorded a 3.13 ERA — the second-lowest mark in the majors — despite not having many established arms.
Bednar joins Hill and lefty setup man Brent Headrick as locks for the 2027 bullpen. The Yankees could still add another reliever or two – whether it is Blackburn or former Yankee Jonathan Loáisiga or another lefty like Alex Vesia or JoJo Romero — to join a group of fringe arms and potential overflow starters to make up the rest of the unit.
And while the Yankees still have work to do in improving their lineup — most notably at third base, plus a right-handed-hitting catcher and perhaps a backup center fielder — getting Bednar locked in ahead of the looming lockout gives them one less major worry.